Buyer's guide · 6 products · prices checked September–November 2026

Is there one app that replaces Jobber, QuickBooks, Gusto and the answering service?

Yes, and for a small electrical contractor the practical answer is Trade Books: dispatch and invoicing, double-entry accounting, payroll and an AI receptionist that answers the business line, in one app for $149 a month flat for up to 10 users on Professional. The four-app stack it replaces — Jobber Grow, QuickBooks Online Essentials, Gusto Simple, Ruby (50 receptionist minutes) — runs $713 a month for a five-person shop. Aptora Total Office Manager and Successware also fold accounting into dispatch (payroll fully in Aptora, gross pay only in Successware) at quote-only prices for larger companies; ServiceTitan covers the four functions at enterprise cost; Housecall Pro and Jobber cover two of the four and sell or sync the rest.

Trade Books is our product. It is in this list because it fits the question; where it doesn't fit, we say so.

The short answer

Replaces all four, small-shop price
Trade Books Professional — $149/mo flat, up to 10 users: dispatch, accounting, payroll and AI receptionist.
Replaces three or four, larger companies
Aptora Total Office Manager (dispatch, accounting, payroll; no AI answering) and Successware (dispatch, accounting, gross payroll) — quote only.
Covers all four at enterprise cost
ServiceTitan — reported $245–$500 per tech per month; accounting module posts to QuickBooks or Intacct, payroll exports to a provider, AI Voice Agent with its phones.
Covers two of four
Jobber Plus (dispatch + AI receptionist, $499 for five) and Housecall Pro (dispatch + payroll and CSR AI add-ons) — QuickBooks stays either way.

What the four-app stack costs a five-person shop

Jobber Grow $299 + QuickBooks Online Essentials $85 + Gusto Simple $79 + Ruby (50 receptionist minutes) $250 = $713 a month, at month-to-month list prices — and that is before the hours spent re-keying hours into Gusto, reconciling the Jobber-to-QuickBooks sync and reading answering-service messages that never made it onto the schedule.

Replacing the stack is only worth it if the replacement does each job properly: a real general ledger, not a QuickBooks sync; payroll that withholds and posts, not a timesheet export; a receptionist that writes the request where the dispatcher works. The list below grades each product on those terms.

Side by side

Published prices read off each vendor's pricing page between September and November 2026. Vendors that sell by quote get a description, not a guess.

1. Trade BooksOurs

Dispatch, estimates, invoicing, double-entry accounting, payroll and an AI receptionist in one app, flat price per tier.

Published price

$49/mo for 1 user · $149/mo flat for up to 10 users · $299/mo flat for up to 50

Accounting
Built-in ledger

Built in on every tier: general ledger, P&L, balance sheet, A/R and A/P aging, bank reconciliation, sales tax, month-end close

Payroll
Built in

Built in from Professional: time clock → approval → pay run, posted to the ledger

AI answering
In the plan

AI receptionist on Professional and up, 200 calls a month in the plan

Best for

HVAC, plumbing, electrical and roofing shops with 1–50 people that want one bill and one set of numbers

2. Aptora Total Office Manager

Contractor ERP: accounting, payroll, job costing, dispatch and inventory in one Windows / hosted application.

Published price
Quote only

Quote only

Accounting
Built-in ledger

Full accounting built in — general ledger, A/P, A/R, bank reconciliation, financial statements

Payroll
Built in

Full payroll built in, including certified payroll

AI answering
None

None

Best for

Larger HVAC, plumbing and electrical companies that want to replace QuickBooks and can run a Windows-based system

3. Successware

Dispatch plus integrated accounting for mid-size HVAC, plumbing and electrical companies.

Published price
Quote only

Quote only

Accounting
Built-in ledger

Integrated accounting with its own general ledger, A/R, A/P and job costing

Payroll
Partial

Accumulates and posts gross earnings to the ledger; it does not keep tax tables, so net pay and filings run through a payroll provider

AI answering
None

None built in

Best for

10–50 truck shops that want the books in the dispatch system and have an office manager to run it

4. ServiceTitan

The enterprise platform: call center, marketing attribution, pricebook pro — priced and implemented like enterprise software.

Published price
Quote only

Quote only. Reported $245–$500 per tech per month, $5,000–$15,000 implementation for a small shop, 12-month contract

Accounting
Module + outside ledger

Accounting module batches invoices and payments and maps GL accounts, then posts to QuickBooks or Sage Intacct — the ledger stays in the accounting package

Payroll
Export only

Payroll module tracks hours, commissions and performance pay, then exports to your payroll provider

AI answering
Paid add-on

AI Voice Agent on ServiceTitan Phones answers and books; priced with the phones product

Best for

Shops past ten trucks with a call center, a marketing budget and an implementation budget

5. Housecall Pro

Consumer-friendly booking, estimates and invoicing; the extras (payroll, AI, phones) are sold as add-ons.

Published price

Basic $79 (1 user) · Essentials $189 (5 users) · MAX $329 (8 users, +$35 each after)

Accounting
Sync to accounting software

QuickBooks Online / Desktop sync; the “Accounting” add-on is a bookkeeping service, not a ledger in the app

Payroll
Paid add-on

Paid add-on, price by quote

AI answering
Paid add-on

CSR AI answers calls and texts — paid add-on, price by quote

Best for

Residential companies that sell online booking and are fine assembling add-ons

6. Jobber

The best-known front-office app for small home-service teams; per-user bundles, QuickBooks for the books.

Published price

Core $49 (1 user) · Connect $139 for 1 / $199 for 5 · Grow $199 for 1 / $299 for 5 · Plus $499 for 5; extra users $29 each

Accounting
Sync to accounting software

QuickBooks Online sync from Connect up — no ledger of its own

Payroll
None

None — time entries sync to Gusto or QuickBooks

AI answering
Top plan

AI Receptionist on the Plus plan ($499/mo for 5 users)

Best for

Solo operators and 2–5 person teams that are happy keeping QuickBooks

1. Trade Books

Ours

All four, one bill, built for shops this size

$49/mo for 1 user · $149/mo flat for up to 10 users · $299/mo flat for up to 50

Trade Books Professional replaces the four line items directly. Dispatch board, estimates, invoicing, texting and payments replace Jobber. A double-entry ledger with bank reconciliation, financial statements, sales tax and month-end close replaces QuickBooks. Payroll from the same time clock replaces Gusto, with no per-employee fee. The AI receptionist answers the business line, captures the job request and transfers to a person, replacing the answering service. $149 a month flat for up to 10 users against $713 for the stack, and the migration from Jobber and QuickBooks is done for you at no charge (20 setup slots a week, first come, first served).

Where it's strong

  • One vendor, one customer list, one ledger — $149 flat
  • Each function is the real thing: ledger, pay runs, receptionist transcripts
  • Free migration from Jobber and QuickBooks exports

Watch for

  • Single-vendor dependency — keep your data exports and ask about them
  • Starter covers dispatch and accounting only; the four-in-one is Professional
  • The receptionist captures requests for the office to confirm; it does not auto-fill the calendar

Trade Books plans and pricing

2. Aptora Total Office Manager

Three of four, for larger companies

Quote only

Aptora Total Office Manager folds dispatch, full accounting and full payroll into one contractor ERP; it has caller ID integration but no AI receptionist, so the answering service stays. It is a Windows or hosted application priced by quote and suited to bigger electrical and HVAC companies with an office team.

Where it's strong

  • Full accounting and full payroll in one system
  • Deep job costing and inventory
  • Built for the trades

Watch for

  • No AI answering
  • Windows / hosted, quote-only, long implementation
  • Heavy for a small shop

3. Successware

Dispatch plus accounting, gross payroll, no phones

Quote only

Successware replaces Jobber and QuickBooks for a 10–50 truck company with its integrated accounting and dispatch, and posts gross payroll earnings to the ledger — but net pay and filings still run through a provider, and there is no AI answering. Quote only.

Where it's strong

  • Integrated accounting and job costing
  • Trade-specific dispatch and agreements
  • Mature

Watch for

  • Payroll provider still needed
  • No AI answering
  • Quote-only, mid-size focus

4. ServiceTitan

All four functions, enterprise bill

Quote only. Reported $245–$500 per tech per month, $5,000–$15,000 implementation for a small shop, 12-month contract

ServiceTitan covers the four jobs — dispatch, an accounting module, payroll management and an AI Voice Agent on its phones — but two of them still end in another product (the ledger in QuickBooks or Intacct, net pay at a payroll provider), and pricing is by quote, reported at $245–$500 per tech per month plus $5,000–$15,000 of implementation on a 12-month contract. For a five-person electrical shop that is more than the stack it would replace.

Where it's strong

  • Every function present at depth
  • AI Voice Agent books against real capacity
  • Enterprise reporting

Watch for

  • Ledger and net pay still live elsewhere
  • Quote-only, contract, paid implementation
  • Costs more than the four apps

Trade Books vs ServiceTitan, in detail

5. Housecall Pro

Two of four in the plan, two as add-ons, QuickBooks stays

Basic $79 (1 user) · Essentials $189 (5 users) · MAX $329 (8 users, +$35 each after)

Housecall Pro replaces Jobber directly and can replace Gusto (payroll add-on) and the answering service (CSR AI add-on, usually with Voice) from the same vendor, each at a quoted price. QuickBooks stays — the “Accounting” add-on is a bookkeeping service in QuickBooks. Fewer vendors than today, not one bill.

Where it's strong

  • Payroll and AI answering available from the same vendor
  • Strong front office
  • No contract

Watch for

  • Add-ons are quoted and stack
  • QuickBooks remains
  • Seat caps (Essentials is 5 users)

Trade Books vs Housecall Pro, in detail

6. Jobber

Jobber Plus removes the answering service, keeps the rest

Core $49 (1 user) · Connect $139 for 1 / $199 for 5 · Grow $199 for 1 / $299 for 5 · Plus $499 for 5; extra users $29 each

Staying on Jobber and upgrading to Plus ($499 for five users) gets the AI Receptionist and drops Ruby — a saving of $50 a month against the Grow-plus-Ruby setup. QuickBooks and Gusto stay, so the stack goes from four apps to three at roughly $663 a month.

Where it's strong

  • No migration
  • AI Receptionist books into the calendar
  • Familiar

Watch for

  • $499 a month for five users
  • QuickBooks and Gusto remain
  • Per-user pricing continues

Trade Books vs Jobber, in detail

How to choose

  1. 1

    Grade each function, not the feature list

    For each candidate ask: can my CPA close the month in it? Does it withhold and post to the ledger, or export a timesheet? Does the receptionist write into the dispatch board? A product that says yes to all three replaces the stack; one that says “integrates” keeps the stack.

  2. 2

    Count the hours, not just the dollars

    The $713 is the visible cost. The sync fixing, timesheet exporting and message re-typing is a few hours a week of the owner's or office manager's time — price that too.

  3. 3

    Protect yourself from single-vendor risk

    Consolidating onto one app means one vendor matters a lot. Confirm you can export customers, invoices, the general ledger and payroll history on demand, and run the old stack in parallel for a month before cancelling.

Questions contractors ask

Is there one app that replaces Jobber, QuickBooks, Gusto and an answering service?

Trade Books Professional does all four — dispatch and invoicing, double-entry accounting, payroll and an AI receptionist — for $149/mo flat for up to 10 users. Aptora covers dispatch, accounting and payroll (no AI answering) for larger companies by quote; ServiceTitan covers all four at enterprise prices with the ledger and net pay still in outside products.

Can one app really replace QuickBooks for an electrical contractor?

If it has a chart of accounts, double-entry journal entries, financial statements, bank reconciliation, sales tax and a period close, yes. Trade Books, Aptora and Successware do; Jobber, Housecall Pro and ServiceTitan integrate with QuickBooks instead. Give your CPA a login and keep your QuickBooks history exported.

What about a human answering service — is AI good enough?

For capturing a caller's name, address, problem and preferred time, and transferring urgent calls to a person, AI receptionists now do the job around the clock for less than Ruby's $250-a-month, 50-minute plan. Test-call it after hours during the trial and read the transcripts before you cancel the service.

How long does consolidating take?

Two to four weeks for a small shop: export customers, jobs, invoices and the pricebook from Jobber and the ledger balances from QuickBooks, import (Trade Books does this for you at no charge), run payroll in parallel for one cycle, forward the business line, then cancel the old subscriptions.

Does the cheapest Trade Books plan replace all four?

No. Starter ($49/mo, one user) covers dispatch, invoicing and accounting. Payroll and the AI receptionist are on Professional ($149/mo flat for up to 10 users).

Other buyer's guides

Go deeper

Published prices read off each vendor's pricing page between September and November 2026; list prices, month to month, before taxes and payment-processing fees. Vendor names are their owners' trademarks. Trade Books is our product. It is in this list because it fits the question; where it doesn't fit, we say so.

Spotted a price that moved? Email [email protected] and we'll re-check it.

Replace the stack in a trial, not a leap

Start the 30-day trial, import Jobber and QuickBooks, run one pay period and one week of calls, and compare the bills.

Start free trial